Just to add a little to OddDuck's suggestions.. It may not "Ping" well if you have some Al dross stuck inside the crucible. Try to clean it out the best you can. I found this with the clay crucibles I've been using for Al so, I imagine it's the same for others.
I stopped using a graphite crucible when a visible crack on the top rim extended down about a third of the way on the outside and I could see it on the inside to the slag line. I heard it pop after an Iron pour, I didn't get it back in the furnace fast enough.
