Some plumbing brass is red brass and sometimes overheating or quick cooling can make the piece red. You can try a good wire brushing to bring the yellow out, might work some.
I picked up some brass at the recycle place that was screw machine stock, Luckily the grade was marked on the end. It has some iron in it and wouldn't mix well with regular brass. If you get any round stock check to see if it's slightly magnetic, and keep it separate. These boys in England have a lot of info on different grades and a pretty nice website.
www.foundry-fopars.co.uk/
Enter the site and go to the top for Brass.
I like their front page tag.
Abandon Hope, All Ye Who Enter Here!